El Sur
Release date: 1983-05-18
Votes: 139
Genres: Drama
A woman recalls her childhood growing up in the North of Spain, focusing on her relationship with her father.
Reviews
badelf
In Victor Erice's luminous "El Sur," the deeply personal becomes profoundly political. This exquisite memory film operates on multiple interlinked planes -- a daughter's coming-of-age, a family fractured by ideology, and a nation emerging from the shadow of authoritarianism. The film's narrative elegance lies in how Estrella's gradual understanding of her father Agustin mirrors Spain's own painful self-examination after Franco. Just as Estrella discovers her father's complex past -- his estrangement from his own father over political differences, his abandoned love in the South -- Spain itself was confronting its buried histories and unresolved divisions in the early 1980s. The Republicans versus Fascists split that drove Agustin from his southern home becomes both literal family drama and national allegory. Erice's visual language is nothing short of transcendent. Jose Luis Alcaine's cinematography transforms ordinary spaces into chambers of memory, where light and shadow perform an intricate dance of revelation and concealment. The film's composition -- often framing characters through doorways, windows, or mirrors -- visually reinforces the theme of divided identities and partial understanding. What makes "El Sur" particularly resonant is that it reflects both personal and collective guilt. Estrella's concluding question about whether she could have done more for her father echoes Spain's own post-Franco reckoning with complicity and silence. If the novella by Adelaida Garcia Morales was indeed a personal reconciliation with her past, Erice expands it into a meditation on national conscience. The famous "incompleteness" of the film -- those southern sequences never filmed due to budget constraints -- becomes its most perfect metaphor. The South remains an abstraction, an idealized elsewhere that exists primarily in imagination and memory. This mirrors both Estrella's incomplete understanding of her father and Spain's unfinished process of reconciliation with its past. "El Sur" suggests that coming-of-age is never merely personal; it happens in historical context (similar themes emerge in "Pan's Labyrinth," "Au Revoir Les Enfants," and "Persepolis"). As Estrella moves from childhood to adolescence, discovering the complexities of adult relationships, Spain itself was navigating its own awkward transition from dictatorship to democracy. Both journeys involve confronting uncomfortable truths, abandoned possibilities, and the realization that some wounds may never fully heal. In its delicate balance of the intimate and the historical, "El Sur" becomes more than a film -- it's a memory palace where personal and national reckonings converge in moments of haunting beauty.
Movie Recommendation
Compulsion1959-04-01Two close friends' plan to execute a flawless crime is crushed when one of them inadvertently leaves his glasses at the crime scene.More...
Why Does Herr R. Run Amok?1970-06-28The life of a married Munich technical draftsman with a son.More...
The Executioner1963-08-31An undertaker gets married to an old executioner's daughter and, although he doesn't like it, must continue the profession of his father-in-law after his retirement.More...
The Secret Life of Words2005-12-15A solitary nurse bonds with a badly burned patient who survived an accident on an oil rig.More...
Taipei Story1985-05-01A young woman urgently seeks to navigate the maze of contemporary Taipei and find a future. She hopes that her boyfriend Lung is the key to the future, but Lung is stuck in a past that combines baseball and traditional loyalty that leads him to squander his nest egg bailing her father out of financial trouble.More...
Empire of Passion1978-09-06In a small Japanese village at the end of the 19th century, a rickshaw driver's wife takes on a much younger lover and the two conspire to murder him.More...
Safe Journey1993-06-06Latcho Drom is a vista of the music, culture, and journey of the Romani people—from their homeland of India, to Europe and Southwest Asia.More...
Mrs. Dalloway1997-09-01Clarissa Dalloway looks back on her youth as she readies for a gathering at her house. The wife of a legislator and a doyenne of London's upper-crust party scene, Clarissa finds that the plight of ailing war veteran Septimus Warren Smith reminds her of a past romance with Peter Walsh. In flashbacks, young Clarissa explores her possibilities with Peter.More...
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Christmas: Cabin Fever2023-12-07A hilarious and heartfelt holiday tale centered around everyone's favorite disaster-prone middle school student, Greg Heffley, which finds him desperately fighting to stay off Santa's naughty list as the family prepares for a major winter snowstorm.More...
Dream of Light1992-10-01Filmmaker Victor Erice follows Spanish artist Antonio Lopez in his painstaking attempt to paint the image of a tree.More...
The Artist and the City1956-11-26The painter António Cruz wanders around the city of Porto painting what he sees: old and modern buildings, people arriving and leaving work in the factories, children playing. The impressionist realism of Cruz’s drawings dissolves into Oliveira’s vision of Porto, which at the same time portrays the painter and his work.More...
American Folk2018-01-26Two strangers, both folk musicians stranded in California, take a road trip to New York in the days after 9/11. A story about the kindness of strangers and the power of music.More...
No Place Like Home2006-09-13When Susan, a film producer from NYC, goes to Jamaica to shoot a shampoo commercial, she finds herself, through a series of unforeseen circumstances, drifting further and further away from the world she knows and into the life of the island, a strange alternative reality that turns many of her previously held assumptions upside down.More...
War and Peace1968-04-28A seven-hour epic adaptation of the novel by Leo Tolstoy. The love story of young Countess Natasha Rostova and Count Pierre Bezukhov is interwoven with the Great Patriotic War of 1812 against Napoleon's invading army.More...
Drunken Angel1948-04-27Doctor Sanada treats gangster Matsunaga after he is wounded in a gunfight, and discovers that he is suffering from tuberculosis. Sanada tries to convince Matsunaga to stay for treatment, which would drastically change his lifestyle. They form an uneasy friendship until Matsunaga's old boss Okada returns from prison.More...
Sauvage2018-08-29Léo, a 22-year-old homeless sex worker searches for genuine love on the streets of Strasbourg.More...
The Spirit of the Beehive1973-10-08In 1940, in the immediate aftermath of the Spanish Civil War, a young girl living on the Castilian plain is haunted after attending a screening of James Whale's 1931 film Frankenstein and hearing from her sister that the monster is not dead, instead existing as a spirit inhabiting a nearby barn.More...
Zelig1983-07-15Fictional documentary about the life of human chameleon Leonard Zelig, a man who becomes a celebrity in the 1920s due to his ability to look and act like whoever is around him. Clever editing places Zelig in real newsreel footage of Woodrow Wilson, Babe Ruth, and others.More...
High and Low1963-03-01In the midst of an attempt to take over his company, a powerhouse executive is hit with a huge ransom demand when his chauffeur's son is kidnapped by mistake.More...
One Cut of the Dead2017-11-04Real zombies arrive and terrorize the crew of a zombie film being shot in an abandoned warehouse, said to be the site of military experiments on humans.More...
Similar Movies
Vantage Point
2008-02-01During an historic counter-terrorism summit in Spain, the President of the United States is struck down by an assassin's bullet. Eight strangers have a perfect view of the kill, but what did they really see? As the minutes leading up to the fatal shot are replayed through the eyes of each eyewitness, the reality of the assassination takes shape.Amarcord
1973-12-18In an Italian seaside town, young Titta gets into trouble with his friends and watches various local eccentrics as they engage in often absurd behavior. Frequently clashing with his stern father and defended by his doting mother, Titta witnesses the actions of a wide range of characters, from his extended family to Fascist loyalists to sensual women, with certain moments shifting into fantastical scenarios.The Royal Tenenbaums
2001-10-05Royal Tenenbaum and his wife Etheline had three children and then they separated. All three children are extraordinary --- all geniuses. Virtually all memory of the brilliance of the young Tenenbaums was subsequently erased by two decades of betrayal, failure, and disaster. Most of this was generally considered to be their father's fault. "The Royal Tenenbaums" is the story of the family's sudden, unexpected reunion one recent winter.The Royal Exchange
2017-12-27After many years of confrontation, the treasures of Spain and France are empty. In 1721, the regent of France draws up an ambitious plan to inaugurate an era of peace and prosperity that will heal the economies of both nations: his intention is to build a solid network of marriage alliances that will involve four children of very different ages who know nothing of betrayals and power games…No Country for Old Me...
2007-06-13Llewelyn Moss stumbles upon dead bodies, $2 million and a hoard of heroin in a Texas desert, but methodical killer Anton Chigurh comes looking for it, with local sheriff Ed Tom Bell hot on his trail. The roles of prey and predator blur as the violent pursuit of money and justice collide.Nobleza baturra
1935-10-11Aragón, Spain, early 20th century. María del Pilar is a honest girl whose good name is dirtied when an old suitor seeking revenge accuses her of losing her virginity outside of marriage. The scandal soon spreads throughout the countryside.Cold War
2018-06-08A man and a woman meet in the ruins of post-war Poland. With vastly different backgrounds and temperaments, they are fatally mismatched and yet drawn to each other.The Elephant Man
1980-10-09A Victorian surgeon rescues a heavily disfigured man being mistreated by his "owner" as a side-show freak. Behind his monstrous façade, there is revealed a person of great intelligence and sensitivity. Based on the true story of Joseph Merrick (called John Merrick in the film), a severely deformed man in 19th century London.4 Months, 3 Weeks and...
2007-08-24Two college roommates have 24 hours to make the ultimate choice as they finalize arrangements for a black market abortion.Secret Sunshine
2007-05-23Shin-ae moves to her recently late husband’s hometown. Despite her efforts to settle in this unfamiliar and too-normal place, she finds that she can’t fit in. After a sudden tragedy, Shin-ae turns to Christianity to relieve her pain, but when even this is not permitted, she wages a war against God.Au Revoir les Enfants...
1987-10-07Au revoir les enfants tells a heartbreaking story of friendship and devastating loss concerning two boys living in Nazi-occupied France. At a provincial Catholic boarding school, the precocious youths enjoy true camaraderie—until a secret is revealed. Based on events from writer-director Malle’s own childhood, the film is a subtle, precisely observed tale of courage, cowardice, and tragic awakening.The Piano Teacher
2001-09-05Erika Kohut, a sexually repressed piano teacher living with her domineering mother, meets a young man who starts romantically pursuing her.Alice in the Cities
1974-05-17German journalist Philip Winter has a case of writer’s block when trying to write an article about the United States. He decides to return to Germany, and while trying to book a flight, encounters a German woman and her nine year old daughter Alice doing the same. The three become friends (almost out of necessity) and while the mother asks Winter to mind Alice temporarily, it quickly becomes apparent that Alice will be his responsibility for longer than he expected.Five Cartridges
1960-11-03It is the year 1936 and the Spanish Civil War is raging. When the German commander of an international brigade is badly wounded he gives his five comrades a message which he divides up and secretes into in five cartridges. All five shells must reach the battalion in order for the message to be relayed. But Frenchman Pierre can’t bear the heat of the Sierra. When he leaves their hide-out to drink from a well he is hit by an enemy bullet.Collin
1981-12-06There is no descriptionThe Young Girls of Ro...
1967-03-08Delphine and Solange are two sisters living in Rochefort. Delphine is a dancing teacher and Solange composes and teaches the piano. Maxence is a poet and a painter. He is doing his military service. Simon owns a music shop, he left Paris one month ago to come back where he fell in love 10 years ago. They are looking for love, looking for each other, without being aware that their ideal partner is very close...Children of Paradise
1945-03-15In a chaotic 19th-century Paris teeming with aristocrats, thieves, psychics, and courtesans, theater mime Baptiste is in love with the mysterious actress Garance. But Garance, in turn, is loved by three other men: pretentious actor Frederick, conniving thief Lacenaire, and Count Edouard of Montray.Lady Snowblood
1973-12-01Yuki's family is nearly wiped out before she is born due to the machinations of a band of criminals. These criminals kidnap and brutalize her mother but leave her alive. Later her mother ends up in prison with only revenge to keep her alive. She creates an instrument for this revenge by purposefully getting pregnant. Yuki never knows the love of a family but only killing and revenge.Le Samouraï
1967-10-25After carrying out a flawlessly planned hit, Jef Costello, a contract killer with samurai instincts, finds himself caught between a persistent police investigator and a ruthless employer, and not even his armor of fedora and trench coat can protect him.Hiroshima Mon Amour
1959-06-10The deep conversation between a Japanese architect and a French actress forms the basis of this celebrated French film, considered one of the vanguard productions of the French New Wave. Set in Hiroshima after the end of World War II, the couple -- lovers turned friends -- recount, over many hours, previous romances and life experiences. The two intertwine their stories about the past with pondering the devastation wrought by the atomic bomb dropped on the city.