El Sur
Release date: 1983-05-19
Votes: 147
Genres: Drama
A woman recalls her childhood growing up in the North of Spain, focusing on her relationship with her father.
Reviews
badelf
In Victor Erice's luminous "El Sur," the deeply personal becomes profoundly political. This exquisite memory film operates on multiple interlinked planes -- a daughter's coming-of-age, a family fractured by ideology, and a nation emerging from the shadow of authoritarianism. The film's narrative elegance lies in how Estrella's gradual understanding of her father Agustin mirrors Spain's own painful self-examination after Franco. Just as Estrella discovers her father's complex past -- his estrangement from his own father over political differences, his abandoned love in the South -- Spain itself was confronting its buried histories and unresolved divisions in the early 1980s. The Republicans versus Fascists split that drove Agustin from his southern home becomes both literal family drama and national allegory. Erice's visual language is nothing short of transcendent. Jose Luis Alcaine's cinematography transforms ordinary spaces into chambers of memory, where light and shadow perform an intricate dance of revelation and concealment. The film's composition -- often framing characters through doorways, windows, or mirrors -- visually reinforces the theme of divided identities and partial understanding. What makes "El Sur" particularly resonant is that it reflects both personal and collective guilt. Estrella's concluding question about whether she could have done more for her father echoes Spain's own post-Franco reckoning with complicity and silence. If the novella by Adelaida Garcia Morales was indeed a personal reconciliation with her past, Erice expands it into a meditation on national conscience. The famous "incompleteness" of the film -- those southern sequences never filmed due to budget constraints -- becomes its most perfect metaphor. The South remains an abstraction, an idealized elsewhere that exists primarily in imagination and memory. This mirrors both Estrella's incomplete understanding of her father and Spain's unfinished process of reconciliation with its past. "El Sur" suggests that coming-of-age is never merely personal; it happens in historical context (similar themes emerge in "Pan's Labyrinth," "Au Revoir Les Enfants," and "Persepolis"). As Estrella moves from childhood to adolescence, discovering the complexities of adult relationships, Spain itself was navigating its own awkward transition from dictatorship to democracy. Both journeys involve confronting uncomfortable truths, abandoned possibilities, and the realization that some wounds may never fully heal. In its delicate balance of the intimate and the historical, "El Sur" becomes more than a film -- it's a memory palace where personal and national reckonings converge in moments of haunting beauty.
Movie Recommendation
Drunken Angel1948-04-27In postwar Tokyo, a blunt, alcohol-soaked doctor diagnoses a swaggering young yakuza with tuberculosis, forging an uneasy bond that’s tested when the gangster’s ruthless former boss returns and drags him back toward the swampy underworld he can’t escape.More...
Compulsion1959-04-01Two close friends' plan to execute a flawless crime is crushed when one of them inadvertently leaves his glasses at the crime scene.More...
Safe Journey1993-06-06Latcho Drom is a vista of the music, culture, and journey of the Romani people—from their homeland of India, to Europe and Southwest Asia.More...
Dream of Light1992-10-01Filmmaker Victor Erice follows Spanish artist Antonio Lopez in his painstaking attempt to paint the image of a tree.More...
The Secret Life of Words2005-12-15A solitary nurse bonds with a badly burned patient who survived an accident on an oil rig.More...
Why Does Herr R. Run Amok?1970-06-28Technical draftsman Herr R. is a dependable guy. He gets along with his colleagues although his boss wants him to go beyond technical cleanliness to problem solving. He's a dutiful husband; his wife's a social climber and pressures him to seek a promotion, but they also share sweet moments. He's a caring father, helping his son with homework. His parents visit; his mother criticizes his wife. Old schoolmates drop by, as do neighbours. Some comment on his wife's expensive tastes. His promotion may be a long shot, especially after he gives a dull and tipsy toast at an office dinner. But why would Herr R. run amok?More...
Bill Cunningham New York2011-03-16Doubling as a cartography of the ever-changing city, Bill Cunningham New York portrays the secluded pioneer of street fashion with grace and heart.More...
Empire of Passion1978-09-06In a small Japanese village at the end of the 19th century, a rickshaw driver's wife takes on a much younger lover and the two conspire to murder him.More...
Extraordinary Stories2008-10-04X arrives in a small town and witnesses a violent act; Z takes the job of a dead manager and discovers that he had a notebook written in code and a map; H is hired to go down a river and investigate a series of mysterious monoliths built on the shore.More...
The Artist and the City1956-11-26The painter António Cruz wanders around the city of Porto painting what he sees: old and modern buildings, people arriving and leaving work in the factories, children playing. The impressionist realism of Cruz’s drawings dissolves into Oliveira’s vision of Porto, which at the same time portrays the painter and his work.More...
American Folk2018-01-26Two strangers, both folk musicians stranded in California, take a road trip to New York in the days after 9/11. A story about the kindness of strangers and the power of music.More...
The Tough Ones 22025-02-19Konsta has just been released from prison and has returned to his people in the countryside. Past grudges drive him back into the drug business, despite the efforts of those around him to keep him on the right track. In the end, Konsta is forced to confront his past in a surprising way and makes a decision that will determine the rest of his life.More...
War and Peace1968-04-28The love story of young Countess Natasha Rostova and Count Pierre Bezukhov is interwoven with the Great Patriotic War of 1812 against Napoleon's invading army.More...
Sauvage2018-08-29Léo, a 22-year-old homeless sex worker searches for genuine love on the streets of Strasbourg.More...
The Spirit of the Beehive1973-10-08In 1940, in the immediate aftermath of the Spanish Civil War, a young girl living on the Castilian plain is haunted after attending a screening of James Whale's 1931 film Frankenstein and hearing from her sister that the monster is not dead, instead existing as a spirit inhabiting a nearby barn.More...
Ip Man: The Final Fight2013-03-22Ip Man reluctantly begins a series of challenges from rival kung fu schools and is soon drawn into the dark and dangerous world of the Triads.More...
The Exterminating Angel1962-05-16After a lavish dinner party, the guests find themselves unable to depart... and, over the next few days, all of their elaborate societal pretenses and façades deteriorate as they are reduced to living like animals.More...
Zelig1983-07-15Fictional documentary about the life of human chameleon Leonard Zelig, a man who becomes a celebrity in the 1920s due to his ability to look and act like whoever is around him. Clever editing places Zelig in real newsreel footage of Woodrow Wilson, Babe Ruth, and others.More...
One Cut of the Dead2017-11-04Real zombies arrive and terrorize the crew of a zombie film being shot in an abandoned warehouse, said to be the site of military experiments on humans.More...
Force Majeure2014-08-15While holidaying in the French Alps, a Swedish family deals with acts of cowardliness as an avalanche breaks out.More...
Similar Movies
The Cheetah Girls 2
2006-07-31Best friends Galleria, Chanel, Dorinda, and Aqua, A.K.A. the girl band "The Cheetahs," get the opportunity of a lifetime when they strut their way to Barcelona, Spain, to perform in an international music festival. Along the way, the "amigas Cheetahs" learn that, although their paths are not the same, they are lucky to have one another for the journey.Take Out
2008-06-06An illegal Chinese immigrant falls behind on payments on an enormous smuggling debt. Ming Ding has only until the end of the day to come up with the money.The Metropolitan Oper...
2011-04-30Verdi’s IL TROVATORE again storms the Met stage in a star-studded, anvil-wielding cast , including Sondra Radvanovsky, Dolora Zajick and Dmitri Hvorostovsky. Marcelo Álvarez sings Manrico, the troubadour of the title. The story is well-known already: The gypsy Azucena has harbored a grudge for thirty years, but she is about to have revenge at last. Meanwhile, her son Manrico is in love with Leonora, but so is his arch-enemy, the Count Di Luna. A pot-boiler, where every tune is a hit.The Graduate
1967-12-21A disillusioned college graduate finds himself torn between his older lover and her daughter.Secret Passage
2004-01-01Isabel and Clara are growing up in a time of terror. It is 1492, and Spain has decreed that all Jews must either convert to Catholicism, go into exile or face trial and execution. Although forcibly baptized, the sisters are chased through Christendom until they arrive in Venice. It is in this great maritime empire, where opulence rhymes with tolerance, that Isabel organizes secret passages for refugees fleeing the Inquisition while Clara falls in love with a Venetian noble, Paolo Zane. Isabel intends for her family to go to Istanbul, the only place where Jews can live freely, but Clara is reluctant to leave. She challenges Isabel's authority and is prepared to break her family ties and sacrifice her faith for love. Caught in this battle of wills is Clara's daughter, Victoria, who finds she is about to be married into the same faith that murdered her father.The Milky Way
1969-02-28Two men, part tramp, part pilgrim, are on their way from France to Santiago de Compostela in Spain. On their way, they meet a vast assortment of characters—some truculent, some violent, and some bizarre; they experience many adventures—some mysterious, some erotic, some even supernatural.Charulata
1964-04-17In 1870s India, Charulata is an isolated, artistically inclined woman who sees little of her busy journalist husband, Bhupati. Realizing that his wife is alienated and unhappy, he convinces his cousin, Amal, to spend time with Charulata and nourish her creative impulses. Amal is a fledgling poet himself, and he and Charulata bond over their shared love of art.Living It Up
2000-10-11Lola, a Mexican waitress working in Madrid, befriends a 30-year-old suicidal man who has borrowed $1,000,000 to spend on his last day on Earth, knowing he will be killed anyway if he fails to return the money. After meeting Lola, however, he decides that life might be worth living after all.Chikamatsu Monogatari...
1954-11-23When the wife of a 17th century Kyoto scroll-maker is falsely accused of having an affair with his best employee, the pair flee the city and find themselves falling for one another.The Human Condition I...
1959-11-20Kaji is sent to the Japanese army labeled Red and is mistreated by the vets. Along his assignment, Kaji witnesses cruelties in the army and revolts against the abusive treatment against the recruit Obara. He also sees his friend Shinjô Ittôhei defecting to the Russian border, and he ends in the front to fight a lost battle against the Russian tanks division.The Human Condition I...
1961-01-28After the Japanese defeat to the Russians, Kaji leads the last remaining men through Manchuria. Intent on returning to his dear wife and his old life, Kaji faces great odds in a variety of different harrowing circumstances as he and his fellow men sneak behind enemy lines.Crossing Borders
2006-03-19In 1960, Martín and Marcos are forced by their difficult personal circumstances to travel to Switzerland in search of work, leaving their families in the Madrid of Franco's Spain. But they undertake more than a simple journey; they begin the road to a new life.Shame
1968-09-29In the midst of a civil war, a pair of former violinists in a tempestuous marriage oversee a farm on a rural island. In spite of their best efforts to escape their homeland, the war impinges on every aspect of their lives.Investigation of a Ci...
1970-10-16Rome, Italy. After committing a heinous crime, a senior police officer exposes evidence incriminating him because his moral commitment prevents him from circumventing the law and the social order it protects.Parasite
2019-05-30All unemployed, Ki-taek's family takes peculiar interest in the wealthy and glamorous Parks for their livelihood until they get entangled in an unexpected incident.Pandora and the Flyin...
1951-04-13Pandora Reynolds is a woman who has never fallen in love – but one who men kill and die for. When she meets dashing and mysterious ship's captain Hendrik van der Zee, he pushes her to commit the ultimate act of love.The Cranes Are Flying...
1957-10-12Veronika and Boris come together in Moscow shortly before World War II. Walking along the river, they watch cranes fly overhead, and promise to rendezvous before Boris leaves to fight. Boris misses the meeting and is off to the front lines, while Veronika waits patiently, sending letters faithfully. After her house is bombed, Veronika moves in with Boris' family, into the company of a cousin with his own intentions.Opening Night
1977-12-22Actress Myrtle Gordon is a functioning alcoholic who is a few days from the opening night of her latest play, concerning a woman distraught about aging. One night a car kills one of Myrtle's fans who is chasing her limousine in an attempt to get the star's attention. Myrtle internalizes the accident and goes on a spiritual quest, but fails to finds the answers she is after. As opening night inches closer and closer, fragile Myrtle must find a way to make the show go on.For Whom the Bell Tol...
1943-07-12Spain in the 1930s is the place to be for a man of action like Robert Jordan. There is a civil war going on and Jordan—who has joined up on the side that appeals most to idealists of that era—has been given a high-risk assignment up in the mountains. He awaits the right time to blow up a crucial bridge in order to halt the enemy's progress.Marriage Story
2019-09-28A stage director and an actress struggle through a grueling, coast-to-coast divorce that pushes them to their personal extremes.